DUTY STATION COMPARISON
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst vs USAG Italy
Air Force, NJ vs Army
The Intel
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst: "Three Bases, One Exit Off the Turnpike." USAG Italy: "173rd Airborne: Jump Pay Buys a Lot of Prosecco." One installation was built for retention. The other was built to test resolve. Both succeed.
The whole-family version of this comparison: Cost of living at both: manageable, which is military code for "you won't go broke, but your spouse has opinions about the grocery bill." For spouses: Strong job market along the NJ Turnpike corridor — pharma, finance, logistics, and healthcare at Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst. At USAG Italy: SOFA on-post positions. The off-post reality that defines day-to-day life: Trenton, NJ versus Vicenza, Italy. Everything else is logistics.
Different uniforms, different installations, same dawning truth: you chose this. On purpose. And you'd probably do it again.
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst
Air Force — NJ
Four seasons, cold winters, humid summers
“Three Bases, One Exit Off the Turnpike”
USAG Italy
Army
Hot summers, cool damp winters, beautiful spring/fall
“173rd Airborne: Jump Pay Buys a Lot of Prosecco”
Category
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst
USAG Italy
Climate
Four seasons, cold winters, humid summers
Hot summers, cool damp winters, beautiful spring/fall
Climate
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstFour seasons, cold winters, humid summers
USAG ItalyHot summers, cool damp winters, beautiful spring/fall
Cost of Living
Medium
Medium
Cost of Living
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstMedium
USAG ItalyMedium
Nearest City
Trenton, NJ (20 min)
Vicenza, Italy (5 min)
Nearest City
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstTrenton, NJ (20 min)
USAG ItalyVicenza, Italy (5 min)
Nearest Airport
Philadelphia International (PHL) — 45 min. Newark Liberty (EWR) — 1 hr. Both are major hubs.
Venice Marco Polo (VCE) — 1 hr; Verona (VRN) — 45 min; Treviso budget airlines (TSF) — 1 hr
Nearest Airport
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstPhiladelphia International (PHL) — 45 min. Newark Liberty (EWR) — 1 hr. Both are major hubs.
USAG ItalyVenice Marco Polo (VCE) — 1 hr; Verona (VRN) — 45 min; Treviso budget airlines (TSF) — 1 hr
Housing
On-base housing available on all three installations — McGuire has the most family housing. Off-base in Mount Holly, Pemberton, and Browns Mills is affordable by NJ standards — $1,400-$1,800 for a 3BR. Further out in Bordentown and Hamilton is pricier but closer to the Turnpike.
On-post at Caserma Ederle and Villaggio — moderate waitlists. Off-post in Vicenza with OHA. Italian apartments have character but may lack American amenities.
Housing
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstOn-base housing available on all three installations — McGuire has the most family housing. Off-base in Mount Holly, Pemberton, and Browns Mills is affordable by NJ standards — $1,400-$1,800 for a 3BR. Further out in Bordentown and Hamilton is pricier but closer to the Turnpike.
USAG ItalyOn-post at Caserma Ederle and Villaggio — moderate waitlists. Off-post in Vicenza with OHA. Italian apartments have character but may lack American amenities.
Spouse Employment
Strong job market along the NJ Turnpike corridor — pharma, finance, logistics, and healthcare. Princeton University area (20 min) has education and biotech. NYC and Philadelphia commutable by train. Remote work is well-supported in the area.
SOFA on-post positions. Off-post restricted. Remote work primary option for professionals.
Spouse Employment
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstStrong job market along the NJ Turnpike corridor — pharma, finance, logistics, and healthcare. Princeton University area (20 min) has education and biotech. NYC and Philadelphia commutable by train. Remote work is well-supported in the area.
USAG ItalySOFA on-post positions. Off-post restricted. Remote work primary option for professionals.
Medical
McGuire Medical Clinic — large clinic but not a hospital. Deborah Heart and Lung Center (10 min) is excellent. Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital in New Brunswick (45 min) for complex care. Philadelphia hospitals are world-class and about 45 min away.
Vicenza Health Clinic — primary care. Medevac to Landstuhl for complex cases. Italian hospitals good.
Medical
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstMcGuire Medical Clinic — large clinic but not a hospital. Deborah Heart and Lung Center (10 min) is excellent. Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital in New Brunswick (45 min) for complex care. Philadelphia hospitals are world-class and about 45 min away.
USAG ItalyVicenza Health Clinic — primary care. Medevac to Landstuhl for complex cases. Italian hospitals good.
Gate Commute
Base spans three installations over 42,000 acres — cross-base drives are 20-30 minutes. Main McGuire gate off Route 539 can back up at peak times. The NJ Turnpike (Exit 7/7A) is the lifeblood and bottleneck — rush hour traffic is real.
Caserma Ederle main gate — minimal delays. Vicenza is small and walkable.
Gate Commute
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-LakehurstBase spans three installations over 42,000 acres — cross-base drives are 20-30 minutes. Main McGuire gate off Route 539 can back up at peak times. The NJ Turnpike (Exit 7/7A) is the lifeblood and bottleneck — rush hour traffic is real.
USAG ItalyCaserma Ederle main gate — minimal delays. Vicenza is small and walkable.
Pros & Cons
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst
PROS
- +NYC and Philadelphia each 1 hour away
- +NJ Pine Barrens recreation
- +Joint service exposure
CONS
- -NJ cost of living and taxes
- -Split installations across large area
- -Jersey Turnpike commute
USAG Italy
PROS
- +Living in Italy — food, wine, culture
- +Venice, Florence, and Dolomites nearby
- +Mediterranean lifestyle
CONS
- -Italian bureaucracy
- -Language barrier for daily tasks
- -Base is small with limited amenities
Known For
Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst
C-17 airliftJoint trainingArmy/AF/Navy joint baseExpeditionary support
USAG Italy
173rd Airborne BrigadeSETAF-AFSouthern European operations
Community Takes
Be the first to share your take on Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst vs USAG Italy
Compare Other Bases
Search by name or state, or browse by branch
VS