Skip to main content
HonestMOS
InvestigationsHow EUCOM shelved a tax break for 9,000 troops in Poland — for five years.
MOS COMPARISON

QM vs AD

Quartermaster (USN) vs Aviation Machinist's Mate (USN)

Intel

Same Navy, same uniform that changes every 4 years, completely different professional realities behind the identical haircuts.

In the recruiter's version: the QM would navigate Navy ships using ECDIS, GPS, radar, and the AD would maintain jet engines on Navy and Marine Corps aircraft. In the version where people actually serve: eCDIS — the Electronic Chart Display and Information System — is the modern tool. And for the AD: your workspace is either a flight deck on a CVN in 40-knot winds or a hangar bay where the temperature is 20 degrees hotter than outside due to reasons nobody can explain. The recruiter's version had better production value. This version has better accuracy. The VA disability claims from these two read like dispatches from different wars. Because they basically are.

QMNavy
Quartermaster
Overall ratingNo reviews yet
Do It Again
Civilian Pay
$88K
ADNavy
Aviation Machinist's Mate
Overall ratingNo reviews yet
Do It Again
Civilian Pay
$100K
Head to Head
QM
AD
Getting In
ASVAB Line Scores
VE_AR 102
VE_AR_MK_AS 210
Clearance
Secret
Pay Grade
Enlisted
Enlisted
Training
Training Length
8 wk
16 wk
Pipeline Type
Boot Camp
Boot Camp
Training Location
Great Lakes, IL
NATTC Pensacola, FL
Day-to-Day
Promotion Speed
Slow
Deployment Tempo
High
Career Field
Navigation
Aviation
After You Get Out
Civilian Median Pay
$88K
$100K
Top Civilian Career
Captains, Mates, and Pilots of Water Vessels
Mechanical Engineers
Credentials Earned
4 certs

After the Uniform

The part the recruiter skips: what each job actually translates to once you're a civilian — and what it pays.

QMQuartermaster
Civilian Median Pay
$88K/yr
What It Becomes on the Outside
Captains, Mates, and Pilots of Water VesselsStrong
Job market: Average (3%)
$88K
Captains, Mates, and Pilots of Water VesselsStrong
Ship EngineersRelated
Job market: Average (4%)
$88K
LogisticiansRelated
Job market: Faster than average (18%)
$79K
Credentials You Walk Away With
Navigation watch qualificationsCelestial navigation proficiencyElectronic chart display certificationsBridge watch qualifications
ADAviation Machinist's Mate
Civilian Median Pay
$100K/yr
What It Becomes on the Outside
Mechanical EngineersStrong
Job market: Average (10%)
$100K
Aircraft Mechanics and Service TechniciansStrong
Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine SpecialistsRelated
Job market: Average (2%)
$54K
Electrical and Electronics Engineering Technologists and TechniciansRelated
Job market: Average (2%)
$64K

Salary data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program. A guide, not a guarantee.

Recruiter vs. Reality

The pitch versus what people who actually did the job report back.

QMQuartermaster
What the Recruiter Says

You'll navigate Navy ships using ECDIS, GPS, radar, and celestial navigation — maintaining the position accuracy and situational awareness that keeps vessels safe in waters where an error has permanent consequences. The QM develops professional mariner skills in a military context that directly supports USCG Merchant Mariner licensing, which opens the Merchant Marine officer career pathway. Commercial shipping, tugboat operations, ferry systems, and maritime training institutions value Navy QM experience as foundational professional mariner preparation. The QM who pursues the USCG licensing pathway and builds the required sea time has access to a maritime career that pays well and operates in environments that reward genuine professional competence.

What It's Actually Like

You are responsible for knowing where the ship is at all times, which sounds simple until you consider that ships move, the ocean floor is not uniform, other vessels have their own ideas about where they're going, and the captain will ask you for a positional update at exactly the moment when you are reconciling three position sources that disagree with each other. ECDIS — the Electronic Chart Display and Information System — is the modern tool. Dead reckoning, celestial navigation, and visual piloting are the skills that exist for when ECDIS fails, GPS is unavailable, or the CO is conducting a competency check. Piloting in and out of port — maneuvering a DDG through a harbor at night in fog — is the highest-stakes routine navigation task and you will own the chart table for it. The navigation brief, the voyage plan, the trackline: these are your products. Undersea hazards, traffic separation schemes, the Rules of the Road: the professional body of knowledge is real and deep. The Merchant Marine navigator pipeline from QM is the most direct of any Navy rate — USCG licensing examiners specifically understand QM experience and the licensing pathway has clear hour requirements that your underway time will satisfy. The maritime industry needs navigators. Your logbook proves you are one.

ADAviation Machinist's Mate
What the Recruiter Says

You'll maintain jet engines on Navy and Marine Corps aircraft — F404s in the F/A-18, F135s in the F-35, T56 turboprops in the E-2C. The technical depth of naval aviation powerplant maintenance is significant, and the FAA Powerplant certificate is directly achievable through military engine experience. Major airlines and MRO facilities are in a persistent competition for A&P-certified technicians with military jet engine experience, and they recruit at Navy transition events specifically for this reason. The pay for an A&P powerplant specialist at a major airline MRO is real money. The Navy is paying for the training.

What It's Actually Like

You will become intimately familiar with the GE F414 and the Pratt & Whitney F100 in ways the engineers who designed them never intended, primarily because you are maintaining them with fewer people and less sleep. Your workspace is either a flight deck on a CVN in 40-knot winds or a hangar bay where the temperature is 20 degrees hotter than outside due to reasons nobody can explain. A jet engine inspection that the manual says takes four hours will take twelve because three of the required tools are on another aircraft, one is missing entirely, and the work order has a typo. You will develop a second sense for the difference between a normal engine noise and an 'oh no' engine noise. Civilian aviation maintenance is absolutely within reach — A&P certification pathway is legitimate — but the Navy will wring every possible flight hour out of you first. The moment you marshal a jet that you fixed and watch it come off the waist cat is the closest thing to pride the aviation world offers.

The Real Life

Same dimensions, side by side. QM on the left, AD on the right.

Daily Life
QM

Navigation — maintaining the ship's charts, plotting courses, standing bridge watches as navigator's assistant, and keeping the ship's log. QMs are the traditional navigators of the fleet. On a ship: standing Officer of the Deck (OOD) assistant watches, maintaining electronic and paper charts, operating navigation equipment, and conducting celestial navigation. Shore duty options are limited and mostly training commands.

AD

Training / School
QM

A School at Great Lakes (IL) is about 8 weeks. Covers chart navigation, piloting, celestial navigation, weather observation, and bridge watch procedures. The training has a romantically traditional feel — you learn to navigate by the stars.

AD

Physical Demands
QM

Low to moderate. Bridge watch standing involves long periods on your feet. Some weather deck work for visual navigation and signaling.

AD

Where You'll Be Stationed
QM
Norfolk (VA)San Diego (CA)Pearl Harbor (HI)Yokosuka (Japan)Various surface ships (DDGs, CGs, CVNs, LHDs)
AD
The Honest Truth
QM

Quartermaster is one of the oldest and most romantic-sounding rates in the Navy — the ship's navigator. The recruiter might pitch celestial navigation and chart plotting, and those skills are real and genuinely cool. What they won't tell you: QM is a small rate with limited advancement and very limited shore duty options. GPS has reduced (but not eliminated) the need for traditional navigation skills, and the rate's future is uncertain. You will spend almost all of your career on ships, which is either a dream or a nightmare depending on your perspective. The civilian translation is narrow but specific: merchant marine, NOAA, and maritime industry positions value QM experience. If you dream of being on the bridge of a ship and navigating by the stars, QM delivers that. If you want career flexibility, look elsewhere. The rate is traditional, meaningful, and increasingly rare — for better and worse.

AD

Recent Reviews

QM
No reviews yet. Be the first to review QM.
AD
No reviews yet. Be the first to review AD.

Community Takes

Be the first to share your take on QM vs AD

Compare Other MOS

Search by code or title, or browse by branch

vs