Skip to main content
HonestMOS
InvestigationsHow EUCOM shelved a tax break for 9,000 troops in Poland — for five years.
DUTY STATION COMPARISON

Presidio of Monterey vs Schofield Barracks

Army, CA vs Army, HI

The Intel

Presidio of Monterey: "Learn Arabic 8 Hours a Day, Walk to the Beach After." Schofield Barracks: "25th ID: Pineapple Express to Poverty." One is what you asked for. The other is what HRC thought you needed. Same Army. Different paperwork.

Presidio of Monterey means Defense Language Institute (DLI) and Foreign language training. Schofield Barracks means 25th Infantry Division and Pacific theater operations. Off-post civilization: Monterey, CA (5 min) versus Wahiawa, HI (5 min). That gap matters more to your quality of life than any duty title. Two of the most expensive stations in the inventory. Your recruiter mentioned neither price tag. Your bank account remembers both. Presidio of Monterey's forecast: Cool, foggy, mild year-round — classic California coast. Schofield Barracks's: Tropical — warm year-round, occasional rain showers. Pack for both. Complain about both. That's the tradition.

Pick your adventure. Or don't — the Army will pick it for you, and your preference was filed under "noted and irrelevant."

Presidio of Monterey
Army — CA
Cool, foggy, mild year-round — classic California coast
Learn Arabic 8 Hours a Day, Walk to the Beach After
Schofield Barracks
Army — HI
Tropical — warm year-round, occasional rain showers
25th ID: Pineapple Express to Poverty
Category
Presidio of Monterey
Schofield Barracks
Climate
Cool, foggy, mild year-round — classic California coast
Tropical — warm year-round, occasional rain showers
Cost of Living
Extreme
Extreme
Nearest City
Monterey, CA (5 min)
Wahiawa, HI (5 min)
Nearest Airport
Monterey Regional (MRY) — 5 min (limited); San Jose (SJC) — 1.5 hrs; SFO — 2 hrs
Daniel K. Inouye International (HNL) — 25 min
Housing
Very limited on-post. Off-post in Monterey, Seaside, Marina — $2,200-$3,500+ for a 3BR. Seaside and Marina more affordable.
Island Palm Communities (PPV) manages on-post housing — waitlists 3-6 months. Off-post extremely expensive — $2,200-$3,500 for a 3BR. Mililani, Waipahu, and Ewa Beach more affordable than Honolulu. COLA helps but does not close the gap.
Spouse Employment
Tourism dominates. Tech jobs in Silicon Valley (1.5 hrs) too far to commute. Remote work most viable.
Tourism and hospitality dominate. Federal and contractor jobs competitive. Professional careers limited vs mainland. Remote work for mainland employers increasingly popular.
Medical
Presidio Health Clinic — primary care only. Community Hospital of Monterey Peninsula for emergencies.
Tripler Army Medical Center (15 min) — full-service military hospital for all of Hawaii. Excellent care across specialties.
Gate Commute
Franklin and Stillwell gates — minimal delays. Post tiny and walkable.
Lyman Road gate and Foote Gate — H-2 freeway to Honolulu backs up during rush hour. Living in Mililani keeps commutes shorter.

By the Numbers

2026 · DFAS

Where the structured table tells you what; this tells you how much.

BAH w/ dep
Presidio of Monterey
Schofield Barracks
Δ at A
E-5
$3,912
E-7
$4,302
O-3
$4,737
MHA: Presidio of Monterey · Schofield Barracks HI408
Tax & Domicile
Presidio of Monterey
Schofield Barracks
State income tax
Hawaii: graduated 1.4% to 11.0% individual income tax for tax year 2024 (per HI Department of Taxation). HI exempts active-duty military pay from HI income tax for non-HI-domiciled SMs (HI Revised Statutes Chapter 235 — military pay exclusion for non-HI SLR). HI-domiciled SMs are taxed on military pay regardless of duty station.
Sales tax
No state sales tax. Hawaii uses the General Excise Tax (GET), which is technically a gross-receipts tax on businesses but functionally passed to consumers: 4% state + 0.5% Honolulu County surcharge = 4.5% combined on Oahu. GET applies to nearly all transactions including groceries and services (broader base than typical state sales tax).
Vehicle reg
HI motor vehicle registration: annual weight tax ($0.75-$2.50 per pound depending on weight, capped) + flat fees + County of Honolulu motor vehicle weight tax. Total typically $200-$500/year for typical passenger vehicles. Annual safety inspection required statewide ($19.19 cap per HRS). No emissions inspection statewide. Out-of-state titled vehicles must register in HI within 30 days of arrival.
Presidio of Monterey · Domicile Play
Schofield Barracks · Domicile Play
SCRA preserves SLR; MSRRA extends to spouses. HI at up to 11% is among the most punitive SLR states for active-duty SMs with significant taxable income. Non-HI SLR (TX/FL/TN/WA) is universally recommended and yields full military-pay exemption. HI SLR is almost never the right play for active-duty unless inherited from HI upbringing with significant local ties.

The Read

What nobody bothers to tell you until you arrive.

Presidio of Monterey
Deep coverage coming for Presidio of Monterey.
Schofield Barracks

Schofield Barracks is the 25th Infantry Division's home — Tropic Lightning — and the structural Army footprint in the Indo-Pacific theater. The 25th ID is the Army's light-infantry/jungle-warfare division aligned to USARPAC and INDOPACOM, and with the strategic shift toward Pacific-deterrence operations (PRC strategic competition, Taiwan-contingency planning, Philippine and Japanese partnership exercises, the Pacific Pathways enterprise) the division is professionally hotter than it's been since Vietnam. The 2nd Infantry Brigade Combat Team and 3rd Infantry Brigade Combat Team are the maneuver brigades; 25th Combat Aviation Brigade flies AH-64E, UH-60M, and CH-47F out of Wheeler Army Airfield (immediately adjacent); 25th Division Artillery (DIVARTY) runs the divisional fires structure. The Jungle Operations Training Center (JOTC) at East Range/Kahuku Training Area runs the Army's only institutional jungle-warfare school, and the Pacific Pathways rotational deployments (to Philippines, Thailand, Indonesia, Australia, Japan) keep brigades engaged regionally on a continuous rotation. The honest financial picture: Hawaii is the most expensive duty station in the U.S. system. BAH for MHA HI408 (Honolulu County, covering all of Oahu including Schofield) — E-5 with deps is $3,912 — which is the highest BAH tier in CONUS-or-territory and sounds enormous until you confront Oahu rent reality: 3BR off-base in the popular military areas runs $2,800-$4,500 (Mililani is the closest, most-popular military bedroom community; Ewa Beach/Kapolei are the West Oahu growth corridor; Waipahu and Pearl City split the difference). COLA (Cost of Living Allowance, the Hawaii-specific OHA structure handled differently from CONUS BAH) supplements but does not close the gap on Oahu's structurally elevated grocery, fuel, utility, and shipping costs. Hawaii state income tax is graduated 1.4-11% (CY2024 per HI DOTAX) — among the most punitive nationally. No state sales tax — instead, a General Excise Tax (GET) of 4.5% on Oahu (4% state + 0.5% Honolulu County surcharge) levied on businesses (functionally passed to consumers). Schools are the structural family-life challenge — HI DOE schools are state-funded and consistently rank below mainland averages; Mililani schools are among the better public options; many career military families choose private (Punahou, 'Iolani, Mid-Pacific Institute, Hawaii Baptist Academy, Saint Louis) at $20-$30k+/year tuition. Island fever is a real phenomenon after 24-36 months and varies by individual.

Pros & Cons

Presidio of Monterey
PROS
  • +Monterey is one of the most beautiful cities in America
  • +World-class food and wine
  • +Ocean views from post
CONS
  • -Extreme cost of living
  • -BAH barely covers rent
  • -Limited military community beyond DLI
Schofield Barracks
PROS
  • +Hawaii lifestyle and beaches
  • +Year-round outdoor activities
  • +Diverse food scene
CONS
  • -Extremely high cost of living
  • -Island fever is real
  • -Far from mainland family

Real Talk

What you’ll actually deal with. The structured table above is the brief — this is the back-channel.

Presidio of Monterey
Deep coverage coming for Presidio of Monterey.
Schofield Barracks
HOUSING

Island Palm Communities (Lendlease-operated privatized housing) manages on-base — extensive inventory across Schofield and Wheeler housing areas; waitlists 3-6 months for popular tiers, longer for the newer phases. On-base is genuinely competitive given the off-base market. Off-base: Mililani (10 min south on H-2, Mililani planned community, the consensus best military bedroom community on central Oahu) is the move; Wahiawa (the small local town immediately outside the gate) is closer and cheaper but more limited; Waipahu (20 min south, mixed residential/commercial, cheaper) is the move for budget-conscious families; Ewa Beach and Kapolei (35-45 min southwest on the West Oahu growth corridor) are newer suburban developments with lower prices but longer commutes; Honolulu/Pearl City (35 min south) is urban and pricey.

SCHOOLS

Hawaii operates a single statewide public school system (HI DOE), which structurally limits the 'pick a better district' option that mainland families have. Schools in central Oahu (Mililani feeders — Mililani Mauka Elementary, Mililani Middle, Mililani HS) and Wahiawa-Whitmore are the better public options for the Schofield catchment; Leilehua HS is the local catchment for Wahiawa/Schofield housing. Career military families frequently choose private schools — Punahou (Honolulu, top-tier prep), 'Iolani (Honolulu, top-tier prep), Mid-Pacific Institute, Hawaii Baptist Academy, Saint Louis (boys, Catholic), and Hanalani Schools (Mililani, the convenient option for Schofield). Tuition at the top schools runs $25-$32k+/year. No DoDEA on Oahu.

COMMAND CLIMATE

25th ID OPTEMPO runs continuously aligned to INDOPACOM theater commitments. Pacific Pathways rotations move brigades through Philippine, Thai, Indonesian, Australian, and Japanese partnership exercises across the calendar. JRTC and NTC rotations (the brigades fly to the mainland for these) plus the Joint Pacific Multinational Readiness Center (JPMRC) Hawaii rotations (the new INDOPACOM CTC standing up at the East Range and Pohakuloa Training Area) drive training cycles. 25 CAB runs alongside. The deployment-to-training ratio is heavier than at most CONUS posts — Pacific posture means continuous regional engagement.

BOTTOM LINE

An assignment whose career signal — INDOPACOM-aligned light infantry, jungle warfare, Pacific partnership — is structurally at a 30-year high, paired with the most expensive cost-of-living environment in the U.S. military system. The Hawaiian lifestyle is real; the financial preparation must be real too.

Who Thrives Here

Not every base is for every service member. Match yourself to the room.

Presidio of Monterey
Deep coverage coming for Presidio of Monterey.
Schofield Barracks
  • 25TH ID LIGHT INFANTRY / JUNGLE-WARFARE CAREERISTS

    25th ID is the Army's light-infantry/jungle-warfare formation. With INDOPACOM strategic emphasis, career signal for 11-series infantry, 13-series light artillery, and aviation careerists is at a 30-year high. The Jungle Operations Training Center credential is unique.

  • PACIFIC PATHWAYS ROTATIONAL FORCE PROS

    Pacific Pathways deployments to Philippines, Thailand, Indonesia, Australia, and Japan provide unique regional-partnership experience and theater-engagement credentialing not available at any CONUS post.

  • HAWAIIAN LIFESTYLE FAMILIES (FINANCIALLY ARMED)

    North Shore surfing, Diamond Head and Manoa Falls hiking, Hanauma Bay snorkeling, year-round outdoor recreation, and the Hawaiian-Asian-Pacific food culture make this one of the highest quality-of-life family tours. The honest gate: you must arrive financially prepared for the cost-of-living shock.

  • INDOPACOM JOINT-STAFF AMBITIOUS OFFICERS

    Proximity to USARPAC HQ (Fort Shafter, 25 min), INDOPACOM (Camp Smith), and the joint Pacific staff infrastructure creates career-ladder opportunity for officers aiming at INDOPACOM joint staff time and theater-strategist careers.

Known For

Presidio of Monterey
Defense Language Institute (DLI)Foreign language training
Schofield Barracks
25th Infantry DivisionPacific theater operations

Community Takes

Be the first to share your take on Presidio of Monterey vs Schofield Barracks

Compare Other Bases

Search by name or state, or browse by branch